Windsor Mill Tavern

301 Main St Unit C, Windsor, CO 80550, USA

About Windsor Mill Tavern

4.6 / 5

from reviews

    Randy Martin
    January 14, 2022

    Very pleasant service. The food wasn't the best I ever had, but it was good. The cheese curds were good, but not worth $9 on happy hour. The chicken strips were good with the fries. That was certainly worth it.

    Aaron Estevez
    January 16, 2023

    I visited for my mom's birthday and had Erica as our waitress. She checked in quickly when we arrived, and things started great. I was impressed with the lively and warm atmosphere. It took a while for us to get drinks, but I didn't think much of it at first. The food was okay, but in general, the quality and quantity did not justify the prices. My lamb wasn't particularly hot when it arrived. I asked for some more horseradish, and by the time that showed up, the lamb was cold. That was disappointing. At the end, we decided to order another round of drinks and pay. The drinks took longer than the box or the check to arrive/be returned. We finally started enjoying the second round of drinks when our waitress Erica came back with the check again. She had given us the wrong check, and she openly admitted that it wasn't the first time she had made this mistake. When I tried to talk to her about it, she ran off before I could express my thoughts, clearly uncomfortable and unwilling to face up to her mistake. It's funny because if we hadn't been waiting for the very slow second round of drinks to arrive, we would have left, so there would be no returning to the table to ask me to pay again. Ironically, she mentioned that if we had left earlier, our whole ticket would be comped, which seemed like a pretty damning thing to say in my view. So basically because we were waiting for the very slow drinks, we ended up having the end of our birthday dinner evening made awkward and weird. It would have been a lot more professional to not mention it and eat the cost. I took the difference out of her tip, and maybe the mistake won't happen a third time. I'm not coming back. There are loads of places dying for business, and when we do take the time to go out on a special occasion, it should be something better than what we get at home (good service, fast and fancy drinks, excellent food, etc.). Nothing we experienced tonight was worth paying the upcharge for. Tldr waitress' repeat mistakes tainted entire evening. When I pay that kind of money, I expect better. Not coming back.

    Ontoneyo Valenzuela
    September 12, 2022

    Great place, very accessible, there is a ramp and elevator. Easy going staff, great bathrooms, acoustics in that place are great. Beautiful astestic, the one thing is that is a bit small. Overall great though.

    Rory Rusinek
    October 30, 2021

    Have been here twice but forgot to review first time. Went here on a Sunday afternoon for a quick family lunch. We started with some cheese curds and a mule. The cheese curds come with a lemon dip which not everyone may like but still tasty. My kiddo ordered the sweet beignets which are good other than a bit much on the powdered sugar. I had fried chicken sandwich which was tasty although is thigh meat so you have to like that. The fries were better the first time. My wife had the Tavern Mac and cheese had a good combination of toppings, the chicken on it is white meat. Overall both times it has been a good experience.

    Alicia Glassmeyer
    July 27, 2021

    Great atmosphere and delicious food. The cheese curds are so crisp and really tasty! The strawberry lemonade is fantastic. Decent burger and fries. A yummy bread pudding was the perfect ending to a nice meal.

    Windsor Mill Tavern

    Our Address

    301 Main St Unit C, Windsor, CO 80550, USA
    Get Directions

    Ad 2

    Ads Title

    Call Attention to Your Restaurant!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!