Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta

1180 Main St, Windsor, CO 80550, USA

About Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta

4.1 / 5

from reviews

    Mandy Toms
    September 06, 2022

    ****Update: Management followed up from review and offered gift card for us to try again. They do acknowledge the poor quality and are trying to make it right. Only giving one star because the two young people that helped when I returned were very polite (and you can't leave no stars)and couldn't believe that the pizza we were given was served - they both even said, "I wouldn't eat that!" This was our second time trying Anthony's - thought we'd give it one more go. Left very disappointed yet again - due to the same issue we had the first time. Pizza was absolutely inedible. Then, when we returned with it they said they could either make another one, which would take about 40 minutes, or I could pick something off of the menu for about the same cost. No refund or gift card, so we were out money from a pizza that would've fed 2-3 people and subbed with pasta for 1, which was less than the pizza so out food and money. They said they couldn't give a refund or gift card because of the app that is used on their website for orders. Very frustrating....extremely disappointed yet again.....adding pictures of a couple of slices my son grabbed and tried to eat - the ENTIRE pizza looked like this:

    Randy Martin
    January 14, 2022

    I always get the chicken Alfredo. It's so good. They need work on the garlic bread though. I was afraid I was going to break a tooth. I couldn't even bite into it. My son got a slice of the thick sicilian with sausage and said it was really good. He returned a couple days later and got it again. Our granddaughter got the neopoitan and loved that.

    Mike Thompson
    October 24, 2021

    ****EDIT**** Someone from Anthony’s corporate team reached out to me. We ended up going back to give it another try and it was excellent! We’ve been back 4-5 times since and each time was very good. I think the original experience was a fluke. Increased rating, great pizza and now our go-to spot for pizza and cheese bread! Where are the toppings and why is it all cold? $1.30 for three half slices of tomato? $1.30 for missing garlic? $6.00 for cold hard mozzarella sticks? I wouldn’t recommend this place. I showed up 8 minutes earlier than my pickup time and the food was already boxed and ready to go. Perhaps they cooked it an hour ahead of time and let it all sit.

    Natalie Schreiber
    September 20, 2022

    Our pizza was so burnt we had to use a butcher knife to cut it and it was still difficult. I do not recommend this place for pizza. But what I do recommend to get is there cheese bread

    Cameron Green
    August 08, 2022

    DISREGARD NEGATIVE REVIEWS...The reviews for the place are so confusing. I am currently sitting here for the 2nd time this week (2nd time ever as well) because of how amazing of an experience it has been. The garlic bread is no doubt the best I have ever had and we were blown away by that. The pizza was fantastic, I saw people complaining about the pizza being "burnt" but this pizza is true to NY style even with the cooking style. The 3 employees were beyond amazing. I have worked in restaurants quite a bit when I was younger and I can say that you aren't finding truly genuine employees like they have here. They are just super nice and caring younger people. My father in law lives in Missouri and he is very upset he doesn't have one there. A+++

    Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta

    Our Address

    1180 Main St, Windsor, CO 80550, USA
    Get Directions

    Ad 2

    Ads Title

    Call Attention to Your Restaurant!

    For more information on our listings, advertising, coupons, and mailers, please contact us today!